I had the great good fortune last week of listening to two of this season’s plays being read aloud. First, I heard a reading of Fetch Clay, Make Man that we produced in NYC. This was the third or fourth reading of the play that I have heard, and it’s a revelation every time. And then on Friday, I was able to stay for the first read-through of Having Our Say. A few months ago I saw an archival video of McCarter’s 1995 production of Having Our Say, but this was the first time I’ve been able to hear that play read live.
Hearing these two plays in dialogue with each other made me think about some of the themes that run through all of the plays in our season. For me, one of the most powerful and resonant themes is of how we shape (or try to shape) our own self-images. The characters in this season’s plays are interested in creating a version of themselves for others to see, and a great deal of the dramatic tension in this year’s plays comes out of the distance and dissonance between the characters themselves and the image they are trying to create. In Having Our Say, as Bessie and Sadie Delany reflect on their lives one hears a difference in how they speak about each other and how they speak about themselves. As African-American women living through 100 years of American history, their lives were filled with situations in which they had to forge a public identity of themselves that doesn’t always match the inner woman. In She Stoops to Conquer, characters disguise themselves, pretending to be lower class in order to, well, conquer. Fetch Clay, Make Man examines very literally what happens to people as they shape their public images—Cassius Clay becomes Muhammad Ali, Lincoln Perry becomes Stepin Fetchit, and even the supporting characters (Sonji Clay, William Fox and Brother Rashid) are in the process of re-shaping their images. They are changing their names and putting on metaphorical masks as they make the man (or woman!) that they will become. American Buffalo concerns three small-time crooks as they posture for each other and negotiate their relationships, and Take Flight tells the story of four pioneers of aviation, trying to shape their legacies.
So I started to wonder why this theme felt so present this season (in a way that it didn’t, for example, last season). Of course, part of it is that three of this season’s plays are about historical characters (the Delany Sisters, Fetchit, Ali, Fox and Clay, and of course the Wright Brothers, Amelia Earhart and Charles Lindbergh). In writing these characters drawn from America’s history book, the playwrights are naturally intrigued by the questions of identity and legacy–who was the private person underneath the public, etc. But perhaps also maybe there’s something about this moment, at least for us here at McCarter, that drew us (unconsiously, I’m sure) to stories that share in an exploration of shaping self-image. As we enter our artistic director’s 20th season and start our first full season with a new managing director, we’ve all spent a lot of time thinking about who we are as a theater right now, and what our identity is in the world and our own community. And as our nation has undergone a massive shift, with democrats winning two of the three branches of our government, and with a president who represents, for many, a very new (and welcome) idea of the image of American leadership, it seems natural that we would be thinking about these questions. Frankly, as America starts to look toward our sister nations and say: “we are a different country now than we were a year ago,” perhaps we are all thinking about identity differently.
What do you think? Coincidence, or is there an underlying trend here?
Posted by Adam Immerwahr, Producing Associate at McCarter Theatre